The Death of Jesus in earliest Persian Translations of Quran up to the 12th Century
Volume 35, Issue 2, November 2022, Pages 153-166
Seyed Hossein Morakabi, Masoud Pourahmadali Tochahi
Abstract The Quran was written in Arabic in the late 6th and early 7th centuries and
is considered by Muslims to be a direct revelation from God to the Prophet
Muhammad. The similarities of concepts between the Quran and the Bible
are so numerous that no one doubts that the Quran was written in
continuation of Judeo-Christian tradition. Nevertheless, the denominations
of Islam living today differ from Christian denominations in fundamental
beliefs, of which the crucifixion of Jesus is one of the most significant. The
most important document of this belief is verse 157 of Sura Nisa in the
Quran, which is very open to interpretation.
After the Prophet died, Arab Muslims attacked their northern neighbor, the
Sassanid Empire, in 633. They were victorious, and since then, Persians
adopted Islam as the state religion. Therefore, it was necessary to translate
the Quran into Persian. To the extent that they have survived to the present
day, these translations provide valuable insights into the early phase of
Islamic culture. The analysis of translations into Persian will show that in all
of the surviving six translations up to the 11th century, the death of Jesus
was accepted, but later theological developments in the central area of the
Islamic world led to a different interpretation of verse 157 of Sura Nisa, and
this new interpretation was able to establish itself as the standard
interpretation. The theological controversies are left aside here, and this
article deals with the issue of the presentation and analysis of the Old
Persian translations of this verse. These syntactic and pragmatic analyses
show that in the ancient translations of the Quran into Persian, the death of
Christ was accepted.
Iran as an origin: On Mahmoud Human’s controversial theses about the beginning moments of Iran’s history
Volume 33, Issue 2, November 2020, Pages 165-191
https://doi.org/10.22034/spektrum.2020.190288
Masoud Pourahmadali Tochahi
Abstract Mahmoud Houman is one of the most important Iranian intellectuals in contemporary Iran. His prominence does not only lie in the diversity of the scientific fields he has approached, or the unique works he has left behind in these research areas, or the relevance of his research questions, or his critical view toward his research subjects, but also in his unique radical theses about the early period of Iran’s history. He has three theses: the first one is about the Iranian foundation of Mesopotamian civilization, the second is about the origins and roots of Aryans in Iran, and the last one is about the age and continuity of pre-Achaemenid Iranian history. What gives these three theses an internal coherence, is the basic idea that Iran is not just an old civilization like the others, but it is also one of the highly creative origins of world civilization. The present article deals with these three theses by Mahmoud Houman and the arguments that substantiate them.
