Ali Shariati and Emile Durkheim's Sociology of Religion
Volume 37, Issue 2, December 2024, Pages 241-257
https://doi.org/10.22034/spektrum.2025.494761.1016
Markus Fiedler
Abstrakt When the Iranian sociologist Ali Shariati came to France in the early 1960s and received his doctorate at the Sorbonne, Paris, in 1964, he was confronted not only with Marxist ideas as a student of sociology, but also with the sociology of religion of Émile Durkheim. For Schariati, who had turned to religion and developed a revolutionary interpretation of Islam, Durkheim's sociology posed a major challenge in several respects. The French sociologist Émile Durkheim is not only credited with establishing sociology as a formal discipline in Europe, but also with giving it a scientific basis by adopting the methods of the natural sciences in the study of society. His methodology stems from positivism, a concept first introduced by the French mathematician and philosopher Auguste Comte (1798-1857). To a certain extent, Durkheim's positivism represented a ‘methodological challenge’ for Schariati, since he rejected everything metaphysical and religious as unscientific. Furthermore, Durkheim is also considered the founder of functionalism, which ultimately only appreciated religion in terms of its social function, which had to pose a problem for Schariati as a religious person for whom religion had a very special meaning. Another important point is that Durkheim believed he had discovered the original religion of humanity in his work Les formes élémentaires de la vie religieuse (‘The elementary forms of religious life’) in his study of totemism in an Australian aboriginal tribe, which was a real challenge for Schariati's thinking. In this article, the three important aspects of Durkheim's sociology of religion will first be briefly presented and the Iranian sociologist Ali Shariati will be briefly introduced to the German reader. Subsequently, Shariati's examination of Durkheim's sociology of religion will be illustrated on the basis of these points and his way of thinking will be highlighted. The results will be summarised at the end.
Allameh Tabatabai as a Sociological Thinker
Volume 37, Issue 1, August 2024, Pages 103-114
https://doi.org/10.22034/spektrum.2024.203854
Markus Fiedler
Abstrakt The renowned Iranian scholar Allameh Tabatabai (1892-1981) left behind a profound body of work that intersects various fields of the humanities. Grounded in his Quranic understanding of humanity as a social being, his writings consistently engage with social themes, seeking to explain the origins and development of human societies. Social issues and aspects of collective identity occupy a significant place in his thought. In sociology, the focus is on explaining societal processes and social change. However, this discipline remains largely Eurocentric and often neglects sociological perspectives outside of Europe and North America. This article aims to highlight the sociological thinking of Allameh Tabatabai, a major Iranian scholar, and introduce it to Western audiences where his work is still relatively unknown. Drawing primarily from his German-translated works such as "ABC des Islam" and "Die Schia im Islam," as well as his Quranic commentary "Al-Mizan," this study introduces Tabatabai's anthropological views and examines his perspectives on social themes. It explores his unique insights into the nature of human society's origins and development based on Quranic principles, addressing questions of historical philosophy and the role of progress in his thought .
